Robert M. Steptoe Jr, Jr., Esq.
400 White Oaks Boulevard
Bridgeport, WV 26330
Hourly Rate $375
Current Steptoe & Johnson PLLC - Member
Practice 32
Cases Approximately 75
Languages English
Steptoe & Johnson PLLC - Member
Attorney, Steptoe & Johnson PLLC, Bridgeport WV, 1971-present; Attorney, Cole, Raywid & Braverman, Washington DC, 1970-71; Active Duty, U.S. Navy, 1965-67.
Has served as mediator in over 25 labor and employment law disputes, raising both statutory and common law claims; 20-25 personal injury actions involving workplace and vehicular issues; 3-5 matters involving insurance coverage issues; approximately 10-15 commercial or construction matters; 3-5 environmental matters involving Clean Water Act, SuperFund, and other issues.
Representative issues handled as a mediator include the following: a construction contract claim relating to a $17M intermodal parking facility; a construction contract claim relating to a ski resort personnel conveyor; a commercial dispute under a customer service agreement for the provision of uniforms and related cleaning services; a Federal Court claim for failure of purchaser to pay for goods sold & delivered; a Federal Court declaratory judgment action involving material misrepresentations in application for fire insurance & complicity of independent agent; a landowner claim in Federal Court against Corps of Engineers involving wetland issues under the Clean Water Act & unconstitutional taking without just compensation; a Federal Court claim against a condominium association involving issues under the WV Condominium Act, including charging of illegal fees and illegal termination of water service; a Federal Court claim against FEMA raising issues under the National Flood Insurance Program by reason of damage to a government-owned building; a Federal Court claim involving serious personal injuries sustained in an auto collision with a tractor-trailer; a PA dispute involving a closely held corporation's "freeze out" of its president, raising issues of cumulative voting, valuation of stock, valuation of goodwill, & questionable financial statements; a NC employment termination raising issues of age discrimination, retaliation, & exempt employee status; a PA civil action involving termination of a restaurant manager raising issues of age discrimination; a WV matter involving employee claims of employer breach of promise to promote & wage discrimination; a Federal Court claim alleging wrongful discharge & intentional infliction of emotional distress by a foreman employed by a major electrical utility; a Federal Court claim alleging serious personal injuries as a result of a highway collision between two trucks; a Federal Court claim involving a multi-year coal purchase agreement & raising issues of Chapter 11 bankruptcy, possessory liens, reclamation requirements, escrowing of money, & value of coal; a Federal Court claim asserting violation of the Family Medical Leave Act raising issues of physical exam, requirement to advise the employer of return to work date, & retaliatory discharge; a Federal Court claim for breach of prison construction "design build" subcontract raising issues of bidder's failure to understand construction drawings, bidding procedures generally, pre-bid meetings, & alleged mutual mistake; a Federal Court personal injury claim involving non-English speaking claimant who sustained serious injuries in motor vehicle collision (mediation required interpreter & presented difficult cultural differences of opinion with respect to appropriate compensation); Virginia employee claims of harassment, denial of promotion, discrimination against disabled veteran, abuses of corporate policy, construction discharge, & defamation; a Federal Court class action claim alleging age discrimination in downsizing of a department store; a Federal Court multi-party claim alleging violation of the WV Consumer and Credit Protection Act in the context of vehicle purchases that were dealer financed with assignment of the paper to a national banking institution (purchasers alleged that liens on the traded vehicles were not satisfied and that taxes and registration fees were not paid to the State); a Federal Court claim under USERRA involving return of veteran to private employment as a security guard; a Federal Court claim asserting failure of insurer to pay under a fire policy, arson defense, mortgagee rights, and fraudulent misrepresentation as to contents on inventory forms; a Federal Court claim alleging serious personal injuries when a utility pole fell on the claimant during the course of his employment; a Federal Court claim for breach of contract to sell multiple radio stations & FCC licenses issues.
As an advocate, has arbitrated approximately 40 labor cases. Further, because civil cases in West Virginia state and federal courts are almost invariably submitted to mediation prior to the Court issuing a trial date, has mediated numerous employment disputes involving both statutory and common law claims. Most of these claims have been the subject of civil actions, but has also mediated agency claims before the EEOC and various state human rights agencies. In addition to employment claims, has been involved in the mediation of workplace accident claims for wrongful death and serious personal injury, particularly in the business of underground coal mining. Also, has mediated numerous personal injury claims in the ski industry, some of which involved paraplegia and other serious injuries.
It is my experience that most litigants prefer the security of a settlement to the risk of a trial, and for that reason I am a pro-active mediator. In preparation for mediation I expect the parties to educate me as to the relevant facts and applicable law. During the course of the mediation I will press each party with respect to strengths, weaknesses, risks, and expected outcomes. In the right cases, and if the parties request, I will make a mediator's proposal. My goal in every mediation is to achieve settlement, but in the absence of settlement, my secondary goal is to insure that the parties have carefully considered their settlement options as well as the risks of trial.
Walt Auvil, Parkersburg WV (304-485-3058),; J. Michael Benninger, Morgantown WV (304-241-1856),; James F. Companion, Wheeling WV (304-233-3390),; John W. Cooper, Parsons WV (304-478-4600),; William H. File, III, Beckley WV (304-253-3358),; Thomas V. Flaherty, Charleston WV (304-345-0200),; Allan N. Karlin, Morgantown WV (304-296-8266),; Elisabeth H. Rose,; Charles S. Trump, Martinsburg WV (304-258-1414),; Charles L. Woody, Charleston WV (304-340-3862),
AAA ACE 19 Case Finances: What Arbitrators Need to Know, 2019; WV State Bar: Advanced Mediation Training 2018: Negotiation Skills for Advocates & Mediators; VA CLE: The Art of Commercial Mediation, 2018; ACE 18 - Arbitrator Performance and Demeanor ~ Meeting Participant Expectations, 2018; AAA Ethical Considerations For Arbitrators, Mediators and Advocates, 2017; WV State Bar: Advanced Mediation Training: The Roadmap to Successful Mediation, 2017; AAA What’s In and What’s Out: Recent Developments In Arbitral Jurisdiction, 2016; AAA The ABC's of Drafting Arbitration Clauses in Individually Negotiated Employment Contracts, 2015; ABA Center for Professional Development: Representing Clients in Mediation: A Master Class in Mediation Advocacy, 2015; AAA Employment & Labor Case Law Update: What Arbitrators and Practitioners Need to Know, 2014; AAA Arbitration Fundamentals and Best Practices, 2011; AAA Arbitration Roadmap: The Standard for Efficient and Cost Effective Arbitration, 2007; AAA Neutrals Conference, including session on Best Practices for Arbitrating Large Complex Cases, 2005; AAA Labor Arbitrator II Training: Advanced Case Management Issues, 2004; AAA Arbitrator Update, 2002; AAA Employment Arbitrator Training, 2000; West Virginia University College of Law, Mediator Training, approximately 1987; WV State Bar/WV Trial Lawyers Association/Defense Trial Counsel of WV Settlement Week Mediator Training in late 1980’s and early 1990’s; various other ADR training.
Admitted to the Bar: West Virginia; Virginia; Pennsylvania.
The West Virginia State Bar (Past President); The West Virginia Bar Association (Past President); Virginia State Bar; Bar of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania; American Bar Association (Labor and Employment Section); The West Virginia Bar Foundation (Fellow and Past President); American Bar Foundation (Fellow and former State Chair); American College of Trial Lawyers (Fellow); The College of Labor and Employment Lawyers (Fellow); and Fourth Circuit Judicial Conference (Permanent Member).
University of Virginia (BA-1965); West Virginia University (JD-1970).
Recognized in The Best Lawyers in America® since 1987 in the fields of Arbitration, Bet-The-Company Litigation, Commercial Litigation, Employment Law–Management, Labor Law–Management, Litigation–Construction, Litigation–Environmental, Litigation–Labor and Employment, and Mediation. Named the Best Lawyers® Morgantown, WV Area Lawyer of the Year in several of these practice areas from 2011-2014. Recognized in Chambers USA America’s Leading Lawyers for Business, and West Virginia Super Lawyers®. Peer review rated AV by Martindale-Hubbell since 1983, and rated AV Preeminent in 2017. Member of the Association of Ski Defense Attorneys. Member of the AAA National Roster of Neutrals. Recipient of the WVU College of Law 2011 Justitia Officium Award. Named to Who’s Who in West Virginia Business by The State Journal for 2007. United Way of Harrison County, President, 1999-2000. Citizen of the Year, Harrison County Chamber of Commerce, 1997. West Virginia Chamber of Commerce, Chairman of the Board, 1997-98. Gavel Award, West Virginia University College of Law, 1986-87. Harrison County Chamber of Commerce, President, 1985-86.
Contributor, "New NLRB Quickie Election Rules Take Effect Today," Steptoe & Johnson PLLC, April 14, 2015; Speaker, "The Case for International Commercial Mediation - Sometimes a Bad Settlement is Better than a Good Lawsuit," TerraLex Network Annual General Meeting, Tokyo, Japan, 2012; Moderator on Federal Employment Laws at Associated Builders and Contractors Construction Industry Summit, 2012; Speaker, “General Employment Issues & Statutes” at Energy & Mineral Law Foundation, Coal Law Short Course, 2010; Speaker, “Labor and Employment: Union Free and Union Operations” at Energy & Mineral Law Foundation, Coal Law Short Course, 2009; Co author, “Workplace Violence Strategies for Coping,” “Labor Relations Guidelines for Small Employers,” and “Other Common Claims Against Employers,” EMPLOYMENT LAW HANDBOOK, West Virginia Chamber of Commerce, published in 2004; Speaker, “Traps in Transactions – the U.S. Employment Lawyer’s Perspective,” TerraLex Network Annual General Meeting, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2001; Speaker, “At-Will Employment Developments in the United States,” TerraLex Network Annual General Meeting, Cologne, Germany, 2000; Co author, “Common Employment Claims,” EMPLOYMENT LAW HANDBOOK, West Virginia Chamber of Commerce, 1996; Author, “Mr. Trumka, If It Ain’t Broke, Don’t Fix It,” 89 WEST VIRGINIA LAW REVIEW 895, 1987; Co author, “You’re Fired (Maybe) – A Review of Expanding Private Sector Employee Rights and Remedies,” WEST VIRGINIA STATE BAR JOURNAL, vol. 9, no. 1, 1984; Co author, “Impact of the NLRA and OSHA upon Law Firms,” Spring, 1981 Issue of Barrister, published by the Young Lawyers Division of the American Bar Association, Spring 1981.
$375 Per Hour
United States of America
Bridgeport, WV

The AAA provides mediators to parties on cases administered by the AAA under AAA mediation procedures. Mediations that proceed without AAA administration are not considered AAA mediations, even where parties select a mediator who is a member of an AAA mediation roster.